JP
    Photo of Judith Ann Pavey
    Judith Ann Pavey
    JP
    Photo of Judith Ann Pavey

    Civil Litigation

    5.0Editorial rating
    Honolulu, HI

    About

    Judith Ann Pavey has over 45 years of experience in litigation and litigation related alternative dispute resolution. She began her litigation career while still in law school where she received a special certification from the Indiana Supreme Court to act as a prosecutor on criminal cases in Marion County juvenile, misdemeanor and felony courts.

    Upon graduation she was hired by a high-profile litigator in Hawai‘i, where she established her reputation as a skilled and successful lawyer in criminal, personal injury and other civil litigation matters. After 7 years, in 1985 Ms. Pavey started her own firm and continued to focus primarily on plaintiffs’ personal injury cases, including those involving medical/legal malpractice and defective products causing substantial physical and/or economic damages. She also continued to handle selected criminal, wrongful termination and sexual harassment cases and worked on construction and contract litigation as well.

    Ms. Pavey was one of the lead litigators representing minority shareholders in a closely held corporation involving a federally regulated institution in which both direct and derivative claims were prosecuted. That was successfully resolved in 2008. That lawsuit brought her to Starn O’Toole Marcus & Fisher in September 2008 where she continues to work on commercial and corporate litigation matters, as well as professional negligence cases involving serious physical and economic damages.

    Ms. Pavey was selected to The Best Lawyers in America®, "Lawyer of the Year" in Honolulu lists, in the practice area(s) of Litigation-Banking & Finance (2013, 2018, 2023), Product Liability Litigation (2014 & 2019) and Medical Malpractice Law (2020, 2023).

    Ms. Pavey is recognized by The Best Lawyers in America® in the practice areas of Medical Malpractice Law, Personal Injury Litigation-Plaintiff, Product Liability Plaintiff, Appellate Practice, Arbitration, Litigation-Banking & Finance, Construction Litigation and Commercial Litigation.

    Ms. Pavey is recognized as a "Litigation Star" by Benchmark Plaintiff, and by Chambers and Partners USA Leading Lawyers for Business in the area of Litigation: General Commercial.

    She has also been selected for inclusion to the Hawaii Super Lawyers® list, Business Litigation, and selected to the 2016 Hawaii Super Lawyers®, "Top 25" list. Ms. Pavey has the highest rating AV® from Martindale-Hubbell® for both her skill and ethics.

    Overview

    Practice focus

    Civil Litigation

    Firm

    Starn O'Toole Marcus & Fisher, A Law Corporation

    Office details

    Location

    733 Bishop Street, Suite 1900
    Honolulu, HI 96813

    Tell us about your case and we connect you with a civil litigation attorney near you. Free to use, no obligation.

    Services

    Practice areas

    Civil LitigationMedical MalpracticePersonal Injury

    Languages

    English

    Reviews

    5.0

    Editorial rating by AttorneyReview

    Be the first client to leave a review

    Share your experience

    Our Opinion

    Editorial review by AttorneyReview

    AttorneyReview TeamEditorial
    10/28/2026

    A Honolulu lawyer for people seriously hurt by professional negligence, including medical mistakes

    Judith Ann Pavey practices at Starn O'Toole Marcus & Fisher, A Law Corporation in Honolulu, and the page traces a long career in litigation. Pavey opened her own firm in 1985 and kept her main focus on injury lawsuits brought by the harmed person, among them claims over medical or legal malpractice and over defective products that caused physical or financial damage. Since moving to Starn O'Toole Marcus & Fisher in September 2008, her work has included professional negligence cases, claims that a doctor, lawyer or other professional fell short and someone suffered serious physical or economic harm as a result. To our eye, a career that started with special permission to prosecute criminal cases while still a law student points to early and steady litigation experience. For someone in Hawaii facing serious physical or financial harm after a medical error or other professional negligence, this profile is worth a closer look. Pavey is a fellow of the Pound Civil Justice Institute, holds licenses in Hawaii as well as Indiana, and earned a JD from Indiana University Bloomington in 1977. Think you have a case? Start here. Tell us about your situation and we connect you with a personal injury attorney near you in Hawaii. Free, no obligation, about two minutes. Injury cases are usually taken with nothing to pay upfront. Editorial opinion by the AttorneyReview team, based on the credentials and practice information on this profile. Not a client review. The attorney did not request, pay for, or review this note. AttorneyReview is a free matching service.

    No reviews yet

    Be the first to share your experience working with Judith.

    Is this your profile?

    Claim it to update details and respond to leads.

    Claim profile

    Credentials

    Bar admissions

    • Indiana, Indiana State Bar Association
    • Hawaii, Hawaii State Bar Association

    Education

    • Indiana University Bloomington, JD, graduated 1977
    • Purdue University, BA, graduated 1973

    Affiliations

    • ABOTA - Member
    • ACLU Hawaii - Member
    • American Association of Justice - Member
    • American Bar Association - Member
    • American Inns of Court - Member
    • Hawaii State Bar Association - Member
    • Hawaii Women Lawyers - Member
    • Pound Civil Justice Institute - Member Fellow